British actor Paapa Essiedu, known for his critically acclaimed role in I May Destroy You and standout performances with the Royal Shakespeare Company, is rumored to be taking on the role of Professor Severus Snape in HBO’s highly anticipated Harry Potter television series.

Essiedu’s potential casting signals a bold direction for the series, which seeks to reimagine J.K. Rowling’s iconic magical world for a new generation. With a stellar résumé that includes Shakespearean roles such as Hamlet and screen credits in Gangs of London and Murder on the Orient Express, Essiedu’s acting prowess has positioned him as a strong contender for the complex role of the potions master.

However, the rumors have sparked controversy among fans of the beloved film series. Many have taken to X (formerly Twitter) to voice their opinions, with reactions ranging from excitement to skepticism.

One fan wrote, “Uhh… is it just me or does Paapa Essiedu not exactly look the part?” Others questioned how the show could match the legacy of Alan Rickman, whose portrayal of Snape in the original films remains iconic.

While some comments expressed frustration with the choice, a broader debate has emerged about the importance of diversifying the series’ cast. “There’s nobody being racist about this; we just want the right actor for this, and Paapa Essiedu isn’t the right one,” one user claimed, while another speculated, “This show is going to tank once they reveal who is playing Harry. The outrage will be insane.”

HBO has yet to confirm any casting decisions for the series, but the speculation alone highlights the immense pressure and scrutiny surrounding the project as it reimagines one of the most cherished franchises in modern pop culture. Essiedu’s supporters, meanwhile, have noted his theatrical depth and ability to bring complexity to challenging roles, arguing he could deliver a fresh take on the character.

‍