Love Island All Stars fans believe they’ve uncovered the real reason Grace Jackson and Luca Bish missed out on victory in the live final. Despite being hot favorites to win this year’s ITV2 reality series, Grace and Luca fell at the final hurdle. In a shock result, host Maya Jama announced Gabby Allen and Casey O’Gorman as the winners, leaving Grace and Luca in second place.

However, many viewers are convinced they know what swayed the vote. One fan speculated online: “It’s all Liv’s fault. She planted doubts in people’s minds, which gave Fiat500 Twitter and Facebook mums even more reason to vote for Gabby’s couple.” Just 24 hours before the final, dumped islander Olivia Hawkins dropped a game-changing bombshell. In a dramatic twist, eleven former islanders returned to the South African villa, and Liv wasted no time stirring the pot. She claimed to have seen a text message in which Grace allegedly said she would “do whatever it takes” to win Love Island All Stars.

Grace fiercely denied the accusation, insisting she never made such a statement. As tensions soared, Maya confronted Liv during the live final, asking: “Absolute scenes when you came into the villa the other day. The question we all want to know—do you have the receipts?” Fixing her gaze on Grace, Liv responded, “I’ve seen them. I’ve said what I’ve said. You know me, I’m very straight-talking. I’m straight to the point. I honestly wish them the best.” Grace, visibly furious, fired back, calling herself just as “straight-talking” and sarcastically adding that she looked forward to “apparently seeing them.” Former Love Island star Mitch Taylor has reportedly admitted that the screenshots were fake and has since been receiving death threats.

Just an hour later, Gabby and Casey were crowned the winners of Love Island All Stars. Now, fans are left wondering—did Liv’s last-minute revelation cost Grace and Luca the crown?